Despite safe and proven alternatives, Pentagon to burn chemical weapons
by Tom Valtin
As the bus pulled up to the gates of the Anniston Army depot in
northeast Alabama, half a dozen police cars were already waiting for us,
along with a bevy of reporters from regional newspapers and network
television affiliates. Three armed troopers stood in the parking lot,
hands on hips, reflector shades gleaming; three more barred the entrance
to the depot, arms folded across their chests.
|Club activists and local residents
protest the Army's plan to incinerate chemical weapons at its Anniston
arms depot, below. Above, John McCown, Club environmental justice
organizer, speaks out at a rally just outside the depot gate.
Sierra Club activist Rufus Kinney, a member of the Anniston-based
Families Concerned about Nerve Gas Incineration and a professor at
nearby Jacksonville State University, stood at the front of the jam-
packed bus and commandeered the microphone. "Let me get off first and
talk to the officers," he said. "I'll let them know this will be a non-
violent protest; we don't want anyone ending up in jail. I'll find out
where we can assemble, and if there's a line past which we can't go.
Then I'll give the signal for you to come out."
The occasion was a June 21 Sierra Club rally in west Anniston, a mostly
poor and African American community that abuts the Army depot, where the
Army wants to fire up a chemical weapons incinerator to destroy the
2,254 tons of outdated but deadly chemical munitions currently stored
there. The Sierra Club, as part of a coalition of environmental justice
and citizens' groups and concerned Anniston residents, is pushing for an
alternative method called neutralization that has been shown to be both
safer and more effective than incineration. The Army is already
committed to using this method at its arms depots in Colorado, Indiana,
Kentucky, and Maryland.
|A young Alabama activist and her mother participate
in the anti-incinerator protest at the gates of the Anniston Army depot.
When Kinney gave the sign, we filed out of the bus. Several additional
carloads of locals and Club activists had pulled up, and they now joined
the busload of 50 or so marchers, chanting "Incineration, no!
Neutralization, yes!" One protester was dressed as the grim reaper,
replete with sickle and gas mask, and marchers carried signs and banners
with messages like, "Environmental justice for all" and "Incineration
hurts children and other living things." One little girl carried a sign
that read, "Children should grow, not glow."
As the TV cameras rolled and reporters scribbled, several speakers
addressed the crowd, including Kinney, Alabama Chapter Chair Neil
Milligan, Club Environmental Justice organizer John McCown, longtime
volunteer Ross Vincent, and several local residents.
"This is Crazy In Alabama taken to a new level," charged Kinney. "There
is zero enthusiasm for the incinerator on the west side of Anniston, but
the people aren't being given a choice."
For upward of 40 years west Anniston residents were subjected to PCB
pollution and other toxic releases produced by the Monsanto (now
Solutia) company's local plant. Some residents now have the highest
concentrations of PCBs in their blood of anyone ever tested – anywhere – and
many people feel it is no coincidence that the Army has located one of
its incinerators in west Anniston, where the local populace has little
political power and has already been poisoned.
"We believe that low-income neighborhoods and communities of color bear
disproportionate environmental burdens in our society," said Milligan to
a gathering/workshop the morning of the protest. The workshop was
sponsored by the Club's Environmental Justice Committee and Alabama
Chapter and attracted Club activists from throughout the South, as well
as local citizens.
Arameta Porter was an Anniston schoolteacher until she was beset with
impaired vision and involuntary facial contortions, which rendered her
unable to work. Her doctors believe she was exposed to nerve agents
leaking from the Anniston depot. Another longtime west Anniston
resident, Jeanette Champion, who has difficulty seeing and walking, told
the audience that she had seen whole families wiped out by cancer. At
her side sat her granddaughter, who had to undergo massive surgery when
she was one day old to correct birth defects that Champion attributes to
"My daddy's liver was destroyed by PCBs," she said. "My children have
seen so much death, and I've had so many of my family die in my arms. If
you live past 57 around here it's a landmark."
Craig Williams, director of the Kentucky-based Chemical Weapons Working
Group (CWWG), described how three years ago, in Tooele, Utah – where
chemical incineration is already under way – deadly sarin gas was released
when rocket pieces jammed in the furnace. "Incineration is a perfect
example of the way you don't want to handle this material," said
Williams, "which is to expose it to heat, change it into a gas, and have
a delivery system in the form of a smokestack." He explained that of the
eight sites where toxic nerve agents are set to be destroyed, the four
that have been given alternatives to incineration have all opted for
neutralization. Alabama has never been given that alternative.
Vincent, a chemical engineer who worked with the Club's Colorado Chapter
to successfully stop incineration in favor of neutralization in Pueblo,
told the crowd that incinerators inevitably release toxic chemicals. "No
matter how many layers of containment they put around it, some of that
material escapes," he said.
In preparation for the incinerator to commence operation, nearly 12,600
protective hoods, 8,571 portable air filtration units, and 9,633
"Shelter-in-Place" units – boxes containing duct tape, plastic sheets, a
towel, scissors, and an instructional videotape – have been distributed to
west Anniston residents by the Calhoun County Emergency Management
Association. But a spokesman for the county said only half the homes in
the so-called "pink zone," the 6-mile swath of homes surrounding the
incinerator, have the safety gear.
"This is the only American community where a civilian population has
ever received gas masks," Kinney told an MSNBC interviewer. "That's not
very reassuring, but we demanded them. [The Army] wouldn't have given us
anything except that we demanded protection we have a right to.
"We're not asking that [the chemical weapons] be moved somewhere else,"
he continued. "We believe that everybody should take care of their own
mess in their own backyard. But the Army is far from having the maximum
protection in place that we have a right to by federal law."
In the aftermath of the weekend workshop, the Sierra Club hired the Rev.
Henry Sterling for a three-month stint as an Alabama organizer, based in
On July 16 the Alabama Department of Environmental Management notified
Alabama Governor Bob Riley that it was nearly ready to let the
incinerator begin a "shakedown period" including trial burns of live
agents. In response, Alabama organizer Peggie Griffin and Club activists
coordinated an effort with the CWWG to flood Governor Riley's office
with phone calls "from far and wide," asking him not to sign the
On July 31, the state issued its final approval, and Army officials
announced their intention to start burning on August 6. On August 4, the
CWWG filed a Temporary Restraining Order petition to the federal court
in Washington, D.C. (An 11th-hour infusion of cash – more than $10,000 of
it from the Sierra Club – helped the CWWG to prepare this restraining
According to Brenda Lindell, of Families Concerned about Nerve Gas
Incineration, the governor requested the Army not start burning the
chemical weapons before granting him the authority to shut down the
incinerator if there were any problems, but this was denied, and the
Army plans to go ahead regardless.
Ever since the June 21 rally at the Army depot, the fight against the
Anniston incinerator has risen startlingly fast from a local issue to a
story of national import. National media, including NBC Nightly News,
CNN, and various cable news networks, have featured segments on
Anniston, and a groundswell of public opposition to the incinerator has
begun to grow. Another, larger anti-incinerator rally is planned in
Anniston on August 16, regardless of whether or not the incinerator has
been fired up.
The people Ross Vincent calls "ragtag activists from small communities
around the country" have made their case that there's a better way to
dispose of chemical weapons than burning them. So far, the Army is not
listening. Residents of Anniston are hoping the federal court will.
Up to Top