| Take Action 1 ACTION plus 1 Article - Updated as of July 18 |
!Take Action on DataCenters !
ACTION
Action: Submit comments on datacenters to City of Fort Worth
Go to the City of Fort Worth data center survey page here and submit comments!
Below is an example for you to use in making your comments.
"The Greater Fort Worth Sierra Club is providing these concerns and comments about the adverse impacts of data center development in Fort Worth and on its environment
and communities. The City must proactively take steps to establish strong data center regulations. Regulations should be established to minimize the negative impact of data centers on Fort Worth’s air quality, water quality and quantity, natural habitat, land use, and noise. Furthermore, regulations should ensure that the health of our communities is not adversely impacted, that overburdened communities do not bear the brunt of high utility costs and other adverse impacts, and that environmental impacts are mitigated by the company, not the City or its citizens through tax dollars. Specific attention should be paid to disproportionate impacts on overburdened and underserved communities. The scheduled Open House is also insufficient. This type of development requires heavy public involvement, thus a committee made up of concerned citizens and experts should be formed to help draft any proposed regulations while a moratorium is in effect.
First and foremost, the City must implement a one-year moratorium1 on all data center approvals and development until the city contracts for an in-depth study using the
standardized Request for Proposal (RFP) evaluation matrix that scores suppliers objectively. The study the City conducted is inadequate and did not thoroughly assess
and evaluate data center development. The proposed regulations that came out of the study fall extremely short on protecting our community.
We are aware there are data centers in Fort Worth, but these are small compared to the many proposed hyper- or large-scale data centers being proposed and already zoned. Our primary concern is the hyperscale data centers. The recommendations below are based on the best available technologies. All of the technologies related to data centers, including IT equipment; energy; water; and HVAC system; are experiencing rapid advances that can lower the costs, energy and water use of data centers.
- Diesel generators lack air pollution controls and emit particulate matter and nitrogen oxides. Data centers use diesel generators to supply their backup
energy generations. As a result, Fort Worth should put in place strong requirements to significantly limit or prohibit data centers from relying on fossil fuel backup generation, including diesel backup generators. Fort Worth should require data centers to be equipped with clean backup sources of power, such as
battery storage and fuel cells using green hydrogen. The very substantial amount of electricity consumed by data centers could offset most or all of the greenhouse
gas savings from our energy efficiency programs and negate the greenhouse gas reductions stemming from renewable energy development. To the extent
possible, data centers should meet electricity demand through net-new renewable energy generation. Fort Worth should require data centers to
implement measures to support net-new renewable energy generation to minimize their impact on overall energy demand. Generators and hundreds, if not
thousands, of cooling fans, produce substantial and harmful noise. The noise persists 24/7 and the high-pitched whines and low-pitched vibrations can travel
for miles. - Currently, most data centers use vast quantities of water which can put severe stress on local water systems. Allowed water usage should be based on
available capacity. Data centers must be connected to municipal water/sewer systems so that all water leaving the site is processed for any contaminants in
the water after it is used. Furthermore, gray water usage should be highly encouraged and/or incentivized. Future technologies that reduce/eliminate water
use should become the norm as they become available. Use of groundwater should be minimized and avoided to the extent possible. There are many
practices that data centers can employ to optimize airflow, reduce HVAC demands, and reduce water usage. Some practices increase the risk related to
data center function and should be discouraged. For example, the so-called “closed loop systems” are very dangerous since the system can produce PFAS
(per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances) and glycol, which are both very harmful to the health of humans, fish and other wildlife. When the system is flushed into
rivers and streams, those contaminants can harm aquatic life downstream. Therefore, any water leaving the site should be required to be treated onsite
before leaving the site. - As mentioned above, noise is a serious issue which causes adverse impacts. Noise reduction and abatement options that provide for safe noise levels should
be required. Allowable noise levels must be based on real-time limits, rather than averages over a particular time frame. - Green space, agricultural, and various conservation areas should not be converted to data center use.
- To ensure proper compliance, a system of monitoring should be required for all data centers in Fort Worth that provides transparency and data access for all
citizens. Data center operators should provide funding and the needed access and instrumentation for all of the following: noise levels, water usage, energy
usage, air and water quality, and the greenhouse gas intensity of the system. Ideally this system would be operated by a third-party company or the City of Fort
Worth, and the data, including historical data, would be available to everyone. - Data centers should not be provided with any tax incentives. The number of jobs created is minor when compared to the adverse impacts
- Pertaining to the proposed regulations, the proposed 250 ft setback from residential is insufficient; 250 ft is only the width of seven average city streets.
The proposed 300 ft setback for generators is also insufficient. The proposed vegetation buffer does nothing to mitigate air emissions from generators or block
the view. Additionally, it does not mitigate the heat island effect from these massive buildings.
In conclusion, data centers do not add to our quality of life, they actually harm it. There are no real community benefits of data centers: they are large buildings that use
massive amounts of water and electricity, use PFAS and other chemicals to keep the system cool, require thousands of acres of otherwise useful or natural land, pull
massive amounts of power from the grid, create the heat island effect which heats our city causing long term climate effects, and remove massive amounts of vegetation and
habitat while only employing minimal number of people. The Greater Fort Worth Sierra Club urges the City to further study the impacts of hyper-scale data centers while
implementing a moratorium while an in-depth study is being conducted. "
---------------------------------------
Read this article of appreciation for Paluxy Valley nature
Nature in Paluxy - a recent birding activity in Paluxy Valley
Birding the Paluxy River Valley
thanks to Joy Havner for this account!
The drive southwest from Fort Worth along HWY 377 takes about 50 minutes. It's the beginning of the Hill Country and closer than I realized.
Our guides, Terry McIntire - FWAS member, Joanne Carcamo, and Jarred Hopson, all locals, welcomed our group onto private properties along the Paluxy corridor, native landscapes that may not look the same much longer.
The birding did not disappoint. In just an hour of birding we had recorded the songs of Golden-cheeked Warblers, an endangered species that nests only in Texas, singing from the Ashe juniper-oak slopes. Blue-gray Gnatcatchers and White-eyed Vireos worked the brush. Carolina Chickadees, Tufted Titmice (hybrids), and both Bewick's and Carolina Wrens kept up a constant chorus in the understory. On the wing we spotted a Great Blue Heron, Red-tailed Hawks, and Turkey Vultures and Black Vultures. American Crows, Greater Roadrunner, and Wild Turkeys rounded out our list.
The warblers weren't the only remarkable find. Two Monarch butterflies, a candidate for the threatened species list, momentarily stopped at plants. On the ground, we found Antelope Horn Milkweed in bloom, a native plant that Monarchs depend on for breeding and survival. Also present was the Glen Rose Yucca, a species considered vulnerable and found in only a handful of locations in the world, this valley among them. Perhaps most striking, and not just because it landed on my shoulder and hung out in my hair for a bit, was an American Bumblebee, an imperiled native bee in North America and also a candidate for threatened species listing. These findings together paint a picture of just how ecologically significant this stretch of the Paluxy really is.
For participant and local, Joanne Carcamo, the morning was both joyful and sobering:
"Being out in the Paluxy at 7:00 AM with our babies, just quiet and bird watching together, was so special. Only twenty minutes into our walk, we heard and then spotted the Golden-cheeked Warbler, it was truly incredible.We were standing only 100 feet from the fence line of the proposed Sailfish Comanche Circle project when we found it. Seeing this endangered bird species so close to that line made it clear how much is at stake. It is so important to my family that we do everything we can to protect this endangered species and the wildlife that shares this land with Dinosaur Valley State Park. We want to make sure this stays as beautiful and peaceful as it is today for our children to grow up in. After all, this is our home. Losing 2,600 acres to industry would be detrimental to the wildlife and the families of the Paluxy who have always called this home. It's so important that we protect this habitat before it's gone."
Terry McIntire, who has long, deep, family roots in the area since the 1850s says "We've treated the land here as an extension of our family. We've tried to be good stewards, especially along the river". I can see how this long relationship of good will with the land makes the development of 2,600 acres feel very personal.
What's the Threat
Two proposed projects would change this valley. Developer Ryan Hughes, Sailfish Investors LLC, has proposed Comanche Circle, Project Panther, and Project Lion a data center complex spanning roughly 2,600 acres near the Hood-Somervell county line, made of nine campuses with up to five gigawatts of capacity, larger than the city of Glen Rose itself. The site sits in a recharge zone for the Upper Trinity Aquifer and within the Paluxy River watershed, with full buildout potentially consuming more than one million gallons of water per day.
Alongside it, Oncor's proposed Dinosaur–Longshore transmission project would run 765-kilovolt lines through Somervell County, with towers up to 140 feet tall on routes that would partially encircle the Dinosaur Valley State Park.
The Fight, and Where It Stands
Local opposition has been fierce. Hood County's own Development Commission recommended a one-year moratorium on large projects like Comanche Circle, but commissioners voted it down twice 3-2, in February, after a state senator threatened legal action against any county attempting such a pause. Over 120 residents rallied at the Somervell County Courthouse against the power lines, and the Public Utility Commission of Texas has received roughly 150 protest comments on proposed transmission routes. TCEQ has received over 11,000 comments opposing the NRG Tolar gas plant permit #181591, which is co located with Comanche Circle.
The fight continues at the state regulatory level and that's where your voice matters now.
How to Help
Protect the Paluxy Valley (protectpaluxy.com) list the action steps (below) and their websites will walk you through them:
Submit comments to the TCEQ opposing air quality permits for the project and requesting a Contested Case Hearing.
Contact the Public Utility Commission of Texas opposing the Oncor transmission routes near the park
Attend the April 15 talk at Fort Worth Botanic Garden (7 PM), Sierra Club speaker Rita Beving on the impact of data centers across Texas - sierraclub.org/texas/greater-fort-worth
The warblers are still singing. But the private lands Terry, Joanne, and Jarred showed us, the native habitat that buffers the park and shelters the birds, and the bees, the butterflies, and the rare plants, are what's at stake.
Another bird walk in this same area will take place on Wednesday May 13th. Want to join or know more? Contact tdmcintire@gmail.com
Resources:
https://www.texastribune.org/2025/12/16/texas-state-park-energy-transmission-line/
https://www.texastribune.org/2026/02/10/texas-hood-county-rejects-data-center-development-pause-ai/
https://www.cbsnews.com/texas/news/power-line-project-looms-over-world-famous-dinosaur-tracks-in-texas-state-park/
https://www.cbsnews.com/texas/news/hood-county-commissioners-reject-data-center-moratorium-again-3-2-vote-residents-call-for-resignations/
https://txswap.org/explore/species/31857
https://www.iucnredlist.org/species/21215172/21215281
https://www.iucnredlist.org/species/22721692/181039629
https://tpwmagazine.com/archive/2013/mar/scout3_florafact_antelopehorn/
https://www.fws.gov/species/monarch-danaus-plexippus
---------------------------------------