NCUC issues carbon plan, pushing Duke Energy's expensive fossil fuel projects forward

The N.C. Utilities Commission issued a carbon plan today that puts North Carolinians at risk of increasing energy bills for polluting methane gas plants while underinvesting in the clean energy resources that are needed to meet state law requirements. The Southern Environmental Law Center intervened in the Carbon Plan proceedings on behalf of the Southern Alliance for Clean Energy, the Sierra Club, and Vote Solar.

The order comes in response to a bipartisan state law requiring monopoly utility Duke Energy to reduce its carbon pollution to net zero by 2050. The plan filed by Duke Energy does not put North Carolina on a sustainable or affordable path to comply with North Carolina law.

Largely approving Duke’s proposal, the plan opens the door to building several risky, expensive gas plants while putting less reliance on the diverse array of clean energy resources that would have saved customers billions of dollars in lost federal tax credits and other cost savings. Endorsing Duke’s massive buildout of new gas plants also puts too much faith in the utility's load growth projections, which includes data centers premised on an uncertain AI future and speculative projects that may never get built.

"It’s unsettling that the Commission is not checking Duke’s dirty plans, including delaying the retirement of expensive, aging coal infrastructure, and not directing Duke to take near-term actions to better ensure compliance with the bipartisan law that requires the utility to reach net zero emissions by 2050," said Mikaela Curry, Beyond Coal Campaign Manager for the Sierra Club. "Duke continues to fail families and small businesses by delaying affordable, clean, and reliable resources that reduce pollution and keep our communities healthier and safer. The NCUC must do a better job of holding Duke accountable."

Earlier this year, the commission issued an order that paused solar and battery procurement and the delay effectively canceled the procurement, making it impossible for 2026. Canceling solar for this year threatens the utility’s progress towards North Carolina’s 2050 carbon pollution reduction requirement goal and risks increased fuel bills for communities already burdened by rate increases.

Throughout the proceedings, the clean energy groups advocated for Duke to take full advantage of energy efficiency, load flexibility, renewables, and storage, which remain the most affordable and fastest suite of options for meeting rising energy demand. These groups also highlighted missed opportunities by Duke in recent years to deploy those clean resources that were included in prior commission-approved carbon plans, which would have saved customers billions of dollars.

Additional responses from clean energy advocates:

"It's disappointing to see Duke continue to miss opportunities to push for deployment of a more balanced portfolio, including wind, pumped hydroelectric storage, and distributed resources like rooftop solar paired with batteries, leaving households on the hook for escalating fuel costs," said David Neal, a senior attorney at the Southern Environmental Law Center. "While we appreciate the Commission's approval of the utility scale solar and battery storage in Duke's near-term plan, we cannot afford to keep delaying the development of a broader array of renewable resources that would lead to significant cost savings and enhanced reliability for customers."

"Duke proposed a resource plan that favors new gas plants, prioritizing their own profits over the long-term interests of North Carolinians," said Maggie Shober, research director for the Southern Alliance for Clean Energy. "Families are already experiencing costly energy bills. If Duke had focused on more affordable renewable resources, families would have some relief from higher bills."

"Time and time again, Duke Energy develops plans that fail North Carolinians in a multitude of ways, and the commission largely approves them," said Jake Duncan, southeast senior regulatory director at Vote Solar. "This was a missed opportunity to develop a plan that recognizes the benefits of solar and other proven clean energy resources that have helped families and businesses across the state relieve the weight of rising energy costs." 


About Us: The Sierra Club is America’s largest and most influential grassroots environmental organization, with tens of thousands of members and supporters in North Carolina. We help people from all backgrounds explore nature and our outdoor heritage, and work to promote clean energy, protect wildlife, safeguard the health of our communities, and preserve our remaining wild places through grassroots activism, public education, lobbying, and legal action.