Edward Smith, edward.smith@sierraclub.org
COLUMBIA, S.C. – A new report, released today by the Sierra Club, reveals how data center projects are on track to reverse 15 years of climate emissions reductions over the next three years and increase local air pollution for nearby communities. The report, Artificial Intelligence, Real Pollution, provides a framework for South Carolina to reduce toxic emissions for communities and the financial impacts on families and small businesses. Voters rejected the high prices they are paying for data centers earlier this month, and the Sierra Club’s guardrails offer solutions.
By 2030, the U.S. could emit 2.3 billion tons of carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions from the electric sector alone, an increase driven by data centers that rely on fossil fuels. This higher level of climate pollution would rival emissions from the U.S. electric sector in 2011, potentially undoing years of progress.
“Voters were loud and clear that they don’t want to pay for data centers this past election,” said Paul Black, Sierra Club’s Senior Campaign Organizer in South Carolina. “It’s time for the PSC to turn the voluntary ratepayer protection pledge into enforceable rules that actually protect South Carolina families and businesses from the impact of data centers. Data center guardrails need to require investment in clean and affordable renewable energy. Clean energy will put downward pressure on our unaffordable monthly bills, make it easier for people to breathe, and limit the frequency and intensity of climate disasters that have impacted our state.”
According to data from RMI:
- in 2023, Duke Energy Carolinas and Duke Energy Progress projected that its emissions would fall 50% (by 15.90 million metric tons) between 2025 and 2035. By 2026, its projected emissions would rise 16% (by 5.56 million metric tons) by 2035, a swing of +66 percentage points.
- in 2023, Dominion Energy South Carolina projected that its emissions would fall 24% (by 2.37 million metric tons) between 2025 and 2035. By 2026, its projected emissions would fall 3% (by 0.25 million metric tons) by 2035, a swing of +21 percentage points.
- in 2023, Santee Cooper projected that its emissions would fall 12% (by 0.71 million metric tons) between 2025 and 2035. By 2026, its projected emissions would rise 3% (by 0.21 million metric tons) by 2035, a swing of +16 percentage points.
Driving increased emissions are nearly 250 gigawatts of new gas-burning power plants that are planned or under construction to power data centers. That is enough to power nearly 75 percent of all U.S. households. Dominion, Duke, and Santee Cooper are part of this trend, and why they received failing grades in the Sierra Club’s Dirty Truth Report released in September.
The Sierra Club’s 2024 Demanding Better framework laid out a path for data center companies to become better actors on climate and pollution, but voluntary adoption has been minimal. Solutions are available, but they will require communities, lawmakers, and regulators to adopt mandatory guardrails for data center developers and utilities.
These guardrails must increase transparency and accountability to ensure data centers do not threaten our health, our environment, and our climate. One impactful solution is to triple solar and double wind on the electric grid to meet U.S. electricity demand. Even with moderate data center growth, these investments would reduce CO2 emissions 25 percent below 2025 levels and reduce average electricity costs by more than $5 billion annually compared to business as usual.
In response, Sierra Club Chief Program Officer Holly Bender issued the following response:
“For over a decade, communities, advocates, and changemakers have stepped up to protect our air and water from toxic pollution and taken swift action to protect our planet from climate change. We have pushed for progress, and won. But now, these artificial intelligence data centers and their power demand threatens to undo all of the work we’ve accomplished.
“Artificial Intelligence, Real Pollution shows the staggering amount of greenhouse gases that would be emitted into our air if we allow data centers and utility companies to continue their rush to fossil fuels. More pollution will worsen the extreme weather families are facing, cause illnesses, and drive up the cost of healthcare and disaster recovery. Just two weeks ago, Americans unequivocally rejected unchecked data centers on the ballot and demanded more accountability, more transparency, and more guardrails. The Sierra Club will continue our work and push for progress that puts our climate and our communities first.”
About the Sierra Club
The Sierra Club is America’s largest and most influential grassroots environmental organization, with millions of members and supporters. In addition to protecting every person's right to get outdoors and access the healing power of nature, the Sierra Club works to promote clean energy, safeguard the health of our communities, protect wildlife, and preserve our remaining wild places through grassroots activism, public education, lobbying, and legal action. For more information, visit www.sierraclub.org.